Skip to main content

Case 43: The One That Stays with You

7 minute read

Tier: AdvancedEstablished patientPatient: Virginia, 91F
A frail woman in her nineties sits at a dining table with a tall stack of unopened mail at one end and a single place setting in front of her, curtains drawn, dishes piled in the kitchen sink beyond.
Primary Diagnosis
General deconditioning following 4-day hospitalization for CHF exacerbation, 7 weeks into episode
Referral Notes
Follow-up visit #19 in ongoing episode, not a new SOC. Original referral 7 weeks ago from Elmwood Regional Hospital after CHF exacerbation admission. Orders at SOC: PT eval and treat 3x/week x 8 weeks, cardiopulmonary training, gait training, fall prevention, HEP, caregiver education. RN 1x/week for medication and cardiac monitoring. OT 1x/week for ADL, discharged at week 3. No SLP. No formal precautions beyond cardiopulmonary parameters. Patient was slowly improving until week 3 when husband collapsed at home and died. Since then, emotional and functional decline. Interim MD communication at week 5: PCP notified of decline, acknowledged grief component, deferred hospice conversation pending family discussion. Today's visit is a scheduled follow-up where continued decline is evident.
Prior Level of Function, the discharge target
Pre-loss (7 weeks ago, SOC baseline): household ambulator with RW at Mod I, modified independent with ADLs, William did cooking and grocery shopping. They walked together daily around the block with William using a SPC and Virginia using her RW. Baked once a week, watched game shows in the evening, called Susan every Sunday. Her identity was tied to her partnership with William.
Vitals on Arrival
BP
108/62
HR
82 irregular
SpO2
92% on RA
Temp
97.8
Pain
0/10
weight 104 lbs on home scale (lost approximately 8 lbs in past 6 weeks per daughter)

Functional Findings:

Functional Findings
15 domains, tap each
Bed Mobility
SBA, declined from independent last week
Episode Expectations
Episode length uncertain pending medical and psychosocial trajectory.
Goals are shifting from restoration to maintenance and comfort.
If PCP and family agree to hospice consult, HHPT may transition to hospice PT or close with warm handoff.
If she stabilizes emotionally with pharmacologic antidepressant, grief counseling, and family support, HHPT could continue 2-3 more weeks toward a revised discharge at assisted household ambulation with RW and caregiver.
Do not project a clean endpoint, acknowledge the uncertainty honestly in the POC update.

The Twist: Virginia is declining functionally despite fair physical capacity. The decline is grief-driven, not disease-driven. She is losing weight, not eating, not doing her HEP, and has told you she does not see the point of therapy. Her SpO2 is 92% and her CHF and COPD are her medical floor. She is not suicidal but she has stopped caring about living. And when she takes your hand at the end of the visit and says 'please do not go, you are the only one who comes,' you have to get in your car and drive to the next patient.

“

This is the case that stays with you. Not because it is the hardest clinically, but because it is the heaviest emotionally.

Discussion Questions:
  1. 1.This patient's functional decline is driven by grief, not by disease progression. How does this change your clinical approach?
  2. 2.She has not eaten a full meal in 4 days and her SpO2 is 92%. What are the immediate medical concerns and who do you notify?
  3. 3.PHQ-2 is positive. She reports no interest in activities and persistent hopelessness. What is your next clinical action?
  4. 4.She asks you not to leave. How do you handle this moment with compassion while maintaining professional boundaries?
  5. 5.After this visit, you sit in your car and feel the emotional weight of what you just experienced. Walk through what you actually do in the next 10 minutes before driving to your next patient. What works for you to keep that weight from following you into the next home?