Skip to main content

Case 40: The Family Accuses You

5 minute read

Tier: AdvancedEstablished patientPatient: Doris, 82F
An older woman sits in a fabric recliner with a folded blanket over its arm, a rolling walker parked beside it, and a side table holding a covered meal container and a closed pill organizer in a tidy living room.
Primary Diagnosis
General deconditioning following 4-day hospitalization for syncope workup, 4 weeks into episode
Referral Notes
Follow-up visit #9 in ongoing episode, not a new SOC. Original referral 4 weeks ago from Eastside Regional Hospital after admission for syncope, workup unrevealing, orthostatic hypotension suspected. Orders at SOC: PT eval and treat 2x/week x 6 weeks, gait training, fall prevention, transfer training, HEP. OT 1x/week for ADL. No nursing currently, no SLP. No weight-bearing or activity precautions beyond orthostatic caution. Last PTA follow-up note (3 days ago) documented: gait 100 ft with RW at CGA, transfers SBA from all surfaces, HEP well-tolerated with daughter's cueing, recommended continued PT 2x/week x 2 more weeks. Interim communication this week: phone call with daughter on Monday to confirm today's Wednesday visit time, daughter confirmed she would not be home, door would be unlocked, patient would be in the recliner expecting the visit.
Prior Level of Function, the discharge target
Household ambulator with supervision and RW prior to syncope admission. Modified independent with ADLs with daughter's cueing and setup. Did not drive. Widowed 5 years ago. Attended church weekly with daughter, watched daytime television, enjoyed visits from grandchildren.
Vitals on Arrival
BP
130/78
HR
72
SpO2
97%
Temp
98.1
Pain
3/10 low back

Functional Findings:

Functional Findings
13 domains, tap each
Bed Mobility
Independent with bed rail
Episode Expectations
2x/week for 1-2 more weeks, discharge target: return to PLOF of household ambulation with RW at supervision with daughter's cueing, HEP embedded in daughter's daily routine, fall-free on discharge.
The family complaint arriving the day after this visit does not change the clinical trajectory, but episode outcome may be affected if the daughter pursues removal of the PT from the case or a complaint against the agency.
◆Self check
Doris has moderate dementia and nobody else will be home during the visit. What changes?

The Twist: The next day, the daughter calls the agency furious. She says her mother told her "nobody came yesterday." The patient has moderate dementia and does not remember your visit. The daughter accuses you of billing for a visit you did not make and demands you be removed from the case. The agency calls you to investigate.

Discussion Questions:
  1. 1.How do you respond to the agency when they call about the accusation?
  2. 2.What documentation from yesterday's visit supports your case? How does the phone call with the daughter earlier that week factor in?
  3. 3.What documentation habits should you maintain for every visit with cognitively impaired patients to protect yourself in situations like this?
  4. 4.The daughter wants you removed from the case. How do you handle this professionally?
  5. 5.Role-play: the agency calls you. Practice your response.