Skip to main content

Case 41: The Ethical Discharge

5 minute read

Tier: AdvancedEstablished patientPatient: Earl, 78M
An older man and a home health therapist sit in two rocking chairs on a front porch on a bright morning, two coffee mugs on a small table between them and a cane leaning against the railing.
Primary Diagnosis
L total knee arthroplasty (cemented, standard approach), 8 weeks post-op
Referral Notes
Discharge visit in ongoing episode. Original referral 8 weeks ago from Westside Orthopedic Hospital after L TKA, discharged POD 3. Orders at SOC: PT eval and treat 2x/week x 6 weeks, gait training, ROM, strengthening, HEP. OT 1x/week for ADL, discharged at week 4 when goals met. No nursing currently on case. WBAT, no formal precautions. Visit history: 2x/week x 6 weeks, then 1x/week x 2 weeks per re-cert, total of 14 visits completed. Interim MD communication: week 6 ortho follow-up documented excellent progress, recommended continue HEP and discharge from HHPT when goals met. Agency notes on today's schedule: "DC visit. NOMNC was delivered at the prior visit two calendar days ago per the two-day rule; confirm it is signed and on file."
Prior Level of Function, the discharge target
Community ambulator without assistive device pre-surgery. Retired engineer, active in church, walked a local park loop with wife daily, drove locally. L knee pain had limited participation in activities for 2 years prior to surgery.
Vitals on Arrival
BP
134/80
HR
74
SpO2
97%
Temp
97.6
Pain
2/10 L knee with activity

Functional Findings:

Functional Findings
12 domains, tap each
Bed Mobility
Independent
Episode Expectations
This is the discharge visit.
The NOMNC was delivered at the prior visit two calendar days ago per the CMS two-day rule and is signed and on file, DC summary completed, HEP reviewed with progression plan, community wellness resources provided in writing to patient and wife.
No further HHPT visits planned.
If patient proceeds to R TKA in the future, he will re-enter HHPT as a new episode at that time.

The Twist: All goals are met. The patient is functionally independent. Clinically, he should be discharged. But the patient and his wife do not want to be discharged. They enjoy the visits. The patient says you are the only reason he exercises. The wife says she feels safer knowing someone is checking on him. They ask you to continue 1x/week 'just to make sure everything is okay.'

Discussion Questions:
  1. 1.Is it ethical to continue home health services for a patient who has met all goals and no longer meets medical necessity?
  2. 2.How do you have the discharge conversation with a patient who does not want to be discharged?
  3. 3.What resources or alternatives can you offer to address their concerns about safety and motivation post-discharge?
  4. 4.If you continue services beyond medical necessity, what are the legal and reimbursement implications?
  5. 5.Write the discharge summary for this patient.