Skip to main content

Case 36: The Dementia Patient Who Only Works with One Therapist

6 minute read

Tier: IntermediatePatient: Andri, 72M
An older man with dementia sits on a hospital bed in his childhood bedroom while a home health therapist seated on a chair a few feet away holds up a framed photograph from the dresser, a bedside commode and lace curtains behind them.
Primary Diagnosis
Advanced dementia (Alzheimer type, Stage 6 on FAST) with behavioral disturbance and generalized weakness
Referral Notes
Referred by PCP after a recent fall during a transfer attempt with his elderly mother. No hospitalization. Orders: PT eval and treat 2x/week x 6 weeks, gait training, transfer training, caregiver education, HEP. OT eval and treat for ADL and behavioral strategies. MSW for caregiver burden assessment and long-term planning. RN for medication reconciliation and fall risk. No weight-bearing precautions. Fall precautions. Nursing intake note documents "patient resistive to care with new providers, participates with longtime private PT." Mother is decision-maker.
Prior Level of Function, the discharge target
Two years ago: household ambulator with FWW at SBA, transfers at Min A, dependent for ADLs with cueing from mother. Six months ago: CGA to Min A transfers with Marcus, ambulation 30 ft with FWW in familiar hallways during Marcus sessions. Between Marcus visits, mother often manages transfers with patient resisting. Rapid recent decline with new BPSD agitation.
Vitals on Arrival
BP
127/82
HR
78
SpO2
98%
Temp
97.3
Pain: unable to verbalize consistently, patient facial grimacing at times during transfer attempt

Functional Findings:

Functional Findings
15 domains, tap each
Bed Mobility
Max A, pulls at bed rail and yells "no no no" with position changes
Episode Expectations
2x/week for 6 weeks, with realistic framing.
Discharge target: clear documentation of participation status, pain workup if grimacing persists, caregiver training for mother and any new agency staff in behavioral approach, communication with Marcus for consistency, HEP embedded in care routine with mother, consideration of home health PT discharge if skilled need cannot be justified and Marcus remains the only effective provider.

The Twist: Andri screams "no no no" throughout your visit. He refuses sit-to-stand transfers, refuses gait training, and tolerates only passive range of motion with maximum encouragement. However, his mother shows you a video of his personal PT (who comes privately 2-3 times per week) working with him, and in the video, Andri is cooperative and participatory. He participates with one specific therapist and refuses everyone else. You must decide whether to continue the home health referral or discharge for non-participation.

Discussion Questions:
  1. 1.The patient participates with one specific therapist but refuses home health PT. Is this a clinical issue, a behavioral issue, or a relationship issue?
  2. 2.His mother is 90+ and has difficulty understanding the discharge recommendation. How do you communicate this sensitively?
  3. 3.Andri's non-participation is documented across multiple home health visits but he engages fully with Marcus on private sessions. To support a clinical discharge decision rather than leaving him on caseload indefinitely, what specific observations from your visit (PAINAD score during transfer, "no no no" pattern with new providers, mother's video evidence) would you put into the chart, and how would you frame the contrast with Marcus's results so it reads as objective rather than dismissive?
  4. 4.Should you recommend the family continue with the private PT who has a therapeutic relationship, even though that PT is not covered by insurance?