- Physical therapy
- Module 7
- Section 24 of 51
Case 23: The Overbearing Daughter
Tier: IntermediatePatient: Ruth, 76F

Primary Diagnosis
R hip ORIF (intertrochanteric fracture, cephalomedullary nail) following mechanical fall, 6 days post-op
Referral Notes
S/P R hip ORIF at Lakeshore Orthopedic Hospital after a mechanical fall at home, discharged on POD 3. Orders: PT eval and treat 3x/week x 4 weeks, gait training, transfer training, strengthening, HEP. OT eval and treat for ADL. No nursing or SLP on case. WBAT R LE, no formal hip precautions (intertrochanteric ORIF, not arthroplasty). Hospital PT documented: ambulated 40 ft with FWW at CGA, 2 steps at CGA with railing, pain 5/10 with activity.
Prior Level of Function, the discharge target
Community ambulator without assistive device. Independent with all ADLs and IADLs. Drove locally, attended a weekly book club, gardened in raised beds, managed her own household including the 2 entry steps reciprocally with a railing.
Vitals on Arrival
BP
132/78
HR
70
SpO2
97%
Temp
98.2
Pain
5/10 R hip
Functional Findings:
Functional Findings
12 domains, tap each
Bed Mobility
SBA, uses bed rail for self-assist
Episode Expectations
3x/week for 3-4 weeks.
Discharge target: ambulatory 200+ ft with FWW to SPC at Mod I, stair negotiation reciprocal with railing at SBA, independent transfers, HEP performed independently 2x daily, fall prevention plan with patient and daughter aligned.
The Twist: The daughter interrupts your assessment repeatedly. She tells you which exercises her mother should do. She answers questions directed at the patient. She says 'the last therapist was wonderful and did things differently.' She pulls you aside and whispers that she thinks her mother needs more help than she is letting on but 'do not tell her I said that.'
Discussion Questions:
- 1.How do you redirect the daughter without damaging the relationship that your patient depends on?
- 2.The daughter has clinical knowledge as a retired nurse. How do you acknowledge this while maintaining your authority?
- 3.She shared confidential concerns privately. How do you use this information ethically?
- 4.Write a diplomatically-worded note that documents the family dynamic without being judgmental.